The basic difference is that the Founding Fathers wrote the Declaration of Independence and the Framers wrote the Constitution. After all, who knows what kind of lying, undisciplined, narcissistic, unskilled, nepotistic, snake oil con man, and traitorous leader they would elect? So, the Electoral College was a mechanism whereby the people elected Electors from their state "notable" leaders who would actually vote for the President.
Email Opponents of the Electoral College can usually be categorized into three different groups: In regard to the third objection, it is safe to assume that such a statement could be made about a large portion of the Constitution — even the amendments added sincewhen the original document was ratified.
After all, does anyone really believe that the authors of the 14th Amendment intended to legalize abortion on demand in all the states or impose a federal definition of marriage upon all the states, or that they wanted the children of illegal aliens to be automatic citizens of the United States?
The Constitution clearly states that only Congress has the power to declare war, yet presidents of both parties have sent Americans into foreign conflicts repeatedly, especially since World War II, without any such declaration of war by Congress.
This is certainly not what the delegates at the Constitutional Convention intended. He added that giving the task of electing the president to some body other than Congress would enhance his independence, and help provide some check on the legislative branch. Using direct popular election in selecting the president was not seriously considered, as there were simply too many problems with that idea.
Under the federal system established by the Constitution, such a process was simply unworkable. After all, no other officer in the new general government would be chosen by a national election. No doubt a national election commission of some sort would be required, further weakening our federal system of government.
The major debate at the Convention was over how to choose members of Congress. The Great Compromise divided the legislative branch into two houses, with one the Senate having an equal vote for each state, regardless of population.
This was considered so important to the smaller populated states that it is the one provision of the Constitution that can never be changed, even by constitutional amendment.
On the other hand, in a bow to the larger populated states, the House of Representatives would indeed be apportioned by population. The same concern of the smaller states was raised when it came to choosing the president. The Founders feared that the large states would control the presidential election.
This way, the larger states would have more say, but would not be as dominant as they would be with direct, popular vote.
The Constitution is quite explicit on this point: They had apparently assumed that each congressional district would select one elector, with the other two chosen directly by the state legislature.
Hamilton even suggested that the Constitution be amended to require that each state allot its electoral votes by district. However, since the Civil War, all states have awarded all their electoral votes to the candidate who wins the most popular votes in their state although only a plurality is required, not a majority.
Another assumption that the Framers apparently made was that each elector would use his own independent judgment in how to cast his vote. The comparison can be made to members of the House of Representatives. The Constitution provides that if no single candidate receives a majority of the electoral votes, then the House of Representatives shall choose the president.
It took 36 votes before the House finally chose Jefferson. Following the election, in which no candidate managed a majority of the electoral vote, John Quincy Adams won over Andrew Jackson in the House.
This was the last time that the House elected the president. Were no person to win the majority of the electoral votes for vice-president, the 12th Amendment requires that the U. Senate choose the vice-president. The Constitution originally provided that each elector vote for two candidates: The top vote-getter would become president and the person with the second-highest votes would become vice-president.
History records that Burr later killed Hamilton in a duel. It is true that the Electoral College does not operate as it was meant to, but it does continue to serve one central purpose for which it was intended: To win election as president, a candidate must get support from a broad coalition of states across the country.
This is a testimony to the wisdom of the Founding Fathers. Unfortunately, neither seems very likely. The results of the presidential election can, however, be expected to harden the resistance of Republicans to any system of direct popular vote.
With 48 percent of the popular vote, Hillary Clinton would be taking the oath on January 20, as the 45th president of the United States.
These three documents, known collectively as the Charters of Freedom, have secured the rights of the American people for more than two and a quarter centuries and are considered instrumental to the founding and philosophy of the United States. Founding Fathers Distrusted Popular Vote to Pick President The Electoral College was devised as a compromise between those who wanted popular elections for president. The Constitution of the United States The Bill of Rights & All Amendments A highly accessible, easy to use online version full text transcript including the Bill of Rights and the rest of the Amendments with both sequential and subject indexes.
We value our readers and encourage their participation, but in order to ensure a positive experience for our readership, we have a few guidelines for commenting on articles.
If your post does not follow our policy, it will be deleted. No profanity, racial slurs, direct threats, or threatening language. Please post comments in English. Please keep your comments on topic with the article. If you wish to comment on another subject, you may search for a relevant article and join or start a discussion there.The United States Constitution - The U.S.
Constitution Online Constitutional Topic: The Electoral College - The U.S. Constitution Online The Constitutional Dictionary - The U.S. Constitution Online. The Constitution of the United States The Bill of Rights & All Amendments A highly accessible, easy to use online version full text transcript including the Bill of Rights and the rest of the Amendments with both sequential and subject indexes.
The mode of appointment of the Chief Magistrate of the United States is almost the only part of the system which has escaped without severe censure Under the Electoral College. Start studying US History Chapter 7. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Search. The founding fathers believed well informed citizens would choose the president wisely. What ideas/concepts did John Locke contribute to the formation of the United States? The Wisdom of the Founding Fathers or Why the Electoral College must Do its Job. When the Republic known as the United States of America was founded, it was not established as a direct.
Origins of the Electoral College. Contrary to modern perceptions, the founding generation did not intend to create a direct democracy. To the contrary, the Founders deliberately created a republic.